Why Should I Let Someone Take A Child's Toy?

Giving children the opportunity to solve conflicts on their own allows children to come up with varied, authentic responses to conflict, all of which have real-world parallels and importance. What is the benefit to minimal intervention for a child that has something taken from them?

How to Mourn a Loss

Everyone experiences loss in their life. When a child loses something they wanted, cries, and is supported through those feelings by nearby adults, they learn how to deal with these powerful emotions without being overwhelmed. They learn that even when things don’t work out the way they wanted, they can find someone willing to listen, and how to recover. After a while they will feel ready to move on.

How to Let Go

While our society definitely values persistence, a healthy balance in life also requires knowing when to give up. Sometimes a battle really just isn’t worth the effort, and that’s just fine. Knowing when to call it quits is something to be proud of. Giving up on one thing usually means saying yes to something else, so giving up can be a very powerful tool in the right situation.

How to Learn from Someone Else’s Ideas

Sometimes children react to loss with curiosity instead of distress.

Here is an example from my nanny work with toddler Z...

Z saw another child at the park pick up his toy airplane.

"Mine!" Zack reached after the plane. The other child moved away, and Z came to sit in my lap to cry. We talked about what had happened. While he settled, he watched as the other child took the plane to the top of the slide.

“Doing?” Z asked. The other child sent the plane down the slide, and it skidded down towards us at top speed. Z was delighted and ran to give the plane back to the other child, saying, “Fly! Again!” Then they practiced sending the plane and a toy car down the slide together.

Z was building the understanding that another child may have an interesting idea about using a toy. This is related to developing theory of mind, the ability to understand that other people think differently than you do.

How to Prepare for Next Time

A child that experiences loss feels motivation to develop new strategies for interacting with children. They learn there are many options for solving a conflict, like trading one toy for another, moving away from the other child, or just hanging on tight. Each one of these strategies is a useful preview for solving adult conflicts.

If we give children opportunities to solve conflicts with minimal guidance (we ensure safety and narrate), some of the time toys will get taken. It can be very difficult for us adults to see this, but it helps to keep in mind that there is something to be learned even in those difficult moments. By providing children with these opportunities, we help them become resilient, empathetic, and flexible.

#sharing #play #playgroups #conflict

Respectful Caregiving

Christina Vlinder

San Francisco Bay Area

Education for Nannies and Parents

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Pinboard
  • Flickr Social Icon

© 2019 by Christina Vlinder.